In a perfect world, how much would publishers pay authors?

As a fifteen-year veteran of the publishing industry, let me answer this question in two ways: first as an idealist, then as a pragmatist.

As you look through the world of publishing and try to find the right opportunity for you and your book manuscript, I want you to have some important context. For your long-term success, it’s actually as dangerous to be overpaid as it is to be underpaid.

Tough truth: small royalty rates aren’t always greed. Publishing is a tough business.

For this discussion, we’re talking about a book that’s traditionally published through one of the Big-5 companies, or a book that’s published through a legitimate conventional small press (not a “hybrid” or self-publishing company).

While self-published books don’t work this way, these numbers might still provide some real value to a self-publisher in the way you budget and strategize for your project.

If you’re considering starting a small press, pay close attention and learn from a mistake that I made early on.

As an Idealist

Successfully publishing a book has three equal parts. Writing the manuscript, publishing the book, and marketing the book.

This is sometimes hard for authors to swallow—they did all the work of writing the manuscript after all, how could it only be a third? But writing is a business, and if those other two parts aren’t executed well, the book will fail.

Yes, the author invested a lot of time, talent, and creativity into their manuscript, and that has real value. But so does the time, talent, creativity and money of the publisher that makes the other two parts work.

When it comes to publishing the book, we’re talking about the expense of editing and designing the book. We’re also thinking about any upfront expense for Advance Review Copies (ARC) and physical inventory that’s needed. We’re also thinking about the relationships, time, and logistics that go into getting the book into the right stores at the right time at the right price. That all has value.

A book needs real expertise in all of those areas, and everyone involved also needs to get paid what they’re worth.

When we look at marketing the book, it’s the same: time, talent, creativity, and money—all of which are necessary to do a good job.

It’s hard to make an apples-to-apples comparison—what are creativity and expertise worth?—but each of these three areas are equally critical to success, and in many ways are roughly equal inputs to the system.

Investment and return should be comparable right? If I pay for 100% of the cost to start a business, I should be entitled to 100% of the profit, right? If I provide half of the startup capital, I should be entitled to half of the profits, right?

Right off the bat, that means the author should be entitled to about 33% of the profit from the book.

In publishing, we call profit “NET.” NET is the money that’s left over after the publisher pays the real distribution expenses for the book—like printing and shipping.

For a book that sells for $15, the retailer usually takes 55%. That leaves $6.75 for the publisher before printing, which probably means that NET will be around $3.

This is pretty convenient for our numbers. Idealistically, if we split this into three equal parts, the author would get $1, the publisher would get $1, and then whoever is responsible for the marketing (which could be the author, the publisher, or someone else) gets $1, too.

However, even in an ideal world, businesses have overhead. Your publisher has costs just to be a business that don’t have anything to do with your particular book, and we should account for that. If we allow 20% for the publisher’s overhead, that leaves 80% to be split three ways, or about 27% for person who wrote the manuscript.

For the sake of our example, that would leave about $.80 per book sold for the author.

No matter how an author publishes, they’re going to have to do a lot of marketing work. Even so, for a traditional publisher (Big-5) that marketing share (1/3rd) belongs to the publisher.

In a small press context, in an ideal world the author might be entitled to all or part of the marketing share of the revenue, depending upon the expectations that are established.

Some small presses do little to no marketing, while others will do almost all of it. If the author is expected to do the marketing work, they should receive most of that marketing share, potentially bumping their royalty to 54% NET.

In an ideal world, the author and the small press should clearly establish what marketing each party will do and what is expected to be accomplished, and that marketing share should be split accordingly. If the author and publisher are going to split the marketing work and cost equally, then the author would get an additional 13.5%, or about 40% NET all together.

What about the real world?

Conceptually, equal thirds with an accommodation for overhead is lovely. It makes sense. But let’s be pragmatic, how does this work in the real world?

In my small press imprints, this is the model that I use to determine royalties. In fairness, it took me a long time to get here and I don’t need to rely on these projects for my full-time income. Because my full-time gig is now training writers at The Company, I just get to take on the projects that I think are really cool.

Like most business people, when I started out with small press projects, my strategy was to pay authors the smallest amount that was “fair.” Depending on how much marketing weight the author could or would carry, we’d typically pay between 10-20% NET for first-time authors. As far as “fair,” this was still a significantly higher rate than most other publishers would pay them.

What I discovered after many years was that this resulted in too little payment to effectively motivate the author to try very hard. Publishing is a tough game, especially for small presses. If selling a thousand copies only nets the author a few hundred dollars, how hard can they justify working? If they double their efforts and we sell 20% more books, is it really worth it?

Not at those royalty rates it’s not.

What I found is that there’s a lot of value in paying authors more. As a small press, you’ll make more money if your authors are making enough to incentivize them to try really hard. If an author puts in a lot of effort, I want them to feel a difference on their next quarterly check and do it again. And again.

Today, when I take on a new project, we typically pay between 25% and 35% NET, depending on our expectations for the author to market the book.

I put up a lot of cash and expertise to publish a book, so I think it’s fair that I have a respectable chance to recover my investment and make a return. But the author also stands to do very well if the book does well.

My goal is to make the author terribly, wonderfully rich. Even though I’m paying a very high royalty rate, there’s no way the author gets rich without me covering my expenses and also seeing a great return.

Isn’t that what we want? We don’t want anybody to get screwed. We want everybody’s goals to align, we want everyone to win. I want my author to win, and I want my author to want me to win. Makes sense, right?

Perhaps I’m still being idealistic. Because this isn’t typically what we see.

Publishing is a really tough business. Even if you’re really good at it, it’s tough to make real money. I’m not talking about millions, I’m just talking about quit your day job and do this full-time money. As I’ve said, I don’t have that pressure since I have a job I love training writers at The Company.

I don’t think most publishers are bad for paying less than this.

I think most publishers are paying what they can. There’s no governing body of publishing that anybody has to report to so this isn’t a rock solid number, but when it all shakes out, most traditionally published authors (Big-5) are probably making around 7% NET.

And even at that very small rate, it’s not going great for publishers. They continue to try to adapt and merge and fight to stay alive in the modern marketplace. They keep 93% of the money and they’re still barely making it.

They have a huge machine to support. Their overhead is enormous, it wouldn’t surprise me if that 7% isn’t that far off of 1/3rd of whatever’s left over after they pay for the high rise offices and the warehouses and the endless support staff and on and on.

For a traditionally published contract for a first-time author, you don’t have much room to negotiate anyways. You’re usually in a take-it-or-leave-it situation, so it doesn’t matter if it feels fair to you.

For small presses, in practice royalties are all over the map, from that 7% on up.

As an author, be wary of publishers that are paying too much. Just like I want to pay authors enough to incentivize them to do a great job, you need a publisher who is keeping enough to do a great job.

If a conventional small press (not a hybrid or self-publishing company) is paying you much more than 35%, I promise you that they’re not going to provide the marketing or support you need post-publication. How could they?

So what’s fair?

The writing of a manuscript is about 1/3rd of the total investment it takes to produce and market a great book. As the author, you’re bringing about 33% of the necessary inputs to the process.

But in the real world, publishing is a business and businesses have overhead. You want your publisher to have some overhead, because that means that they have the assets in place to execute at the level you need. So your effective royalty (your “NET) is going to scale down from that 33% mark.

While many publishers are paying significantly less than this rate, I don’t think they’re ripping off authors. They’re simply paying what they can afford to pay. They may not be greedy, it’s more likely that their business model is no good. Most big publishers have failed to adapt to the modern marketplace, they’re just bloated, and that shrinks the pot for everyone—from the author to the shareholders.

That doesn’t make it fair or good, either. It’s just a pathetic reality.

Look for small presses that have some overhead. Look for small presses that aren’t overpaying—you need them to do a job for you. But the most effective small presses are going to be the ones that pay their authors enough to incentivize you to do a great job and bring your best to the marketing of your book.

No matter how you publish—self-publishing, small press, or Big-5—you’ll need to participate in the marketing of your book. The most important thing is to know what’s expected of you before you sign on the dotted line, and to make sure that everyone is fairly represented in the royalty rate.

The best royalty rate is the one that makes it impossible for one person to make money without the other members of the team also being fairly represented. The best royalty rate is the one that aligns everyone—author, production team, marketing team—so that you all win together.


Like talking about writing and publishing? Let’s keep doing it!
Join my free newsletter and get helpful stuff in your inbox each week.
Plus I’ll send you the first four chapters of my bestselling book on novel writing right away, totally for free.


Dont miss The Novel Matrix, the #1 Fiction Writing Reference New Release in America. Grab your copy on Amazon today.

The Novel Matrix by Brad Pauquette

No one's born knowing how to write and publish.

It's hard. Learn from my mistakes so that you don't have to make them. Sign up for my free newsletter so that you never miss a thing.

You have Successfully Subscribed!